The Oregon Biz Report - Business News from Oregon

Read about accutane journal moderate acne here

Oregon Supreme Court splits on defining “roof”

October 2, 2010

Oregon Supreme Court splits on defining “roof”
byAter-Wynne,
Oregon Law Firm

Is a plastic tarp a roof? It can be, according to the Oregon Supreme Court, which today remanded for trial a dispute between a homeowner and an insurer. In Dewsnup v. Farmers Insurance Co., the plaintiff undertook to repair the roof of his home. He removed the wood shakes and replaced them with plastic sheeting. On the first night of the repair project, a storm caused the sheeting to come loose, and rain entered the home through joints in the sublayer.

The homeowners’ insurance policy excluded coverage for water damage, except that it would cover damage that resulted if the force of wind caused an opening in the roof. The insurer contended that since the plastic sheeting was not a roof, water damage that resulted when it blew off was not covered. Justice Kistler, after surveying the small body of law on temporary roofing, held that the covering of a house is a roof if it’s “sufficiently durable to meet its intended purpose: to cover and protect a building against weather-related risks that reasonably may be anticipated.” The homeowner offered the testimony of an expert witness regarding the adequacy and functionality of the plastic sheeting as a covering. As a consequence, the court concluded it’s up to a jury to decide whether it served as a “roof” for purposes of the policy.

Justice Balmer, joined by Justice Linder, dissented, stating that no reasonable juror could conclude that the parties intended the term “roof” to include a tarp stapled to the house as a temporary covering. “It is plain that the plastic tarps were not intended to be permanent — they were a temporary expedient, which the homeowner installed on his own after he removed the shakes as part of ‘replacing the roof.'”

  
Print This Post Print This Post    Email This Post Email This Post

Discuss this article

no comments yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top Business News

 

Top Women's News

 

Top Natural Resource News

 

Top Faith News

 

Copyright © 2016, OregonReport. All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Use - Copyright - Legal Policy | Contact Oregon Report

Stay Tuned...

Stay up to date with the latest political news and commentary from Oregon Business Report through daily email updates:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Prefer another subscription option? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, become a fan on Facebook, or follow us on Twitter.

RSS Twitter Facebook

No Thanks (close this box)