The Oregon Biz Report - Business News from Oregon

Read about accutane journal moderate acne here

Don’t blame manufacturing for Oregon’s chronic unemployment

March 5, 2010

For Portland, more bikeways mean fewer paved roads
By Dr. Eric Fuits,
EconInternational

At 11 percent unemployment, Oregon is tied with Alabama for having the ninth highest unemployment in the U.S.  Some politicians and policy makers are cheering the fact that Oregon is not tied for first or second place, as it was a few months ago. Even so, Oregon has occupied a spot in the top ten highest unemployment states in 18 of the past 34 years.

Oregon’s chronic high employment has been a source of bafflement for many observers and economists.

Businesses note that Oregon has an anti-business attitude that treats business a problem to be dealt with rather than an endeavor to foster.  In contrast, others point to surveys that rank Oregon as having one the lowest business tax burdens in the country [1, 2] or being one of the most “business friendly” states in the country. In the face of these studies, Oregon’s persistent high employment rate suggests (1) Oregon is not employment friendly, and/or (2) the various tax burden and business friendly are fundamentally flawed and, therefore, meaningless.

Since so many Oregonian’s do not like to discuss the state’s business environment, observers have tried other explanations for Oregon’s moribund jobs environment, including:

Education
.  If Oregon just spent more money on education, employment in the state would improve.

Climate. Analysts at the Oregon Employment Department have a theory that states with milder climates have higher unemployment rates and (believe it or not) Oregon is considered to have a relatively mild climate.

High minimum wage
.  Although minimum wage workers (and potential works) make up a relatively small portion of the workforce, Oregon’s unemployment rate among those most likely to earn minimum wage is substantially higher than if Oregon’s minimum wage was the same as the Federal rate.
Ultimately, many observers, reporters, and politicians throw up their hands and blame manufacturing.  The story goes like this …

Oregon relies heavily on heavy manufacturing. Heavy manufacturing is highly cyclical: Employment soars during boom times plummets during down times.  Thus, during recessions Oregon’s employment suffers worse than the rest of the country.  The story falls apart for several reasons:

Oregon’s unemployment rate is high even during boom times.  If the manufacturing story were true, during economic booms Oregon’s unemployment rate should drop faster and/or be lower than the rest of the country’s.

Oregon does not rely that heavily on heavy manufacturing.  According to the Oregon Employment Department, throughout the U.S. heavy manufacturing accounts for approximately 6.1 percent of employment.  In Oregon, it accounts for 8.3 percent. It not clear that this is enough of a difference to explain the state’s persistently high unemployment.

Other states that rely more heavily on heavy manufacturing do not have persistently high unemployment.  According to the Oregon Employment Department, Wisconsin, Iowa, and New Hampshire have a greater share of their employment in heavy manufacturing, yet these state have much lower unemployment than Oregon.  In fact the Oregon Employment Department produced the following graph that concludes that “there seem to be other factors that have a stronger correlation to the unemployment rate than the concentration of durable goods employment.”

  
Print This Post Print This Post    Email This Post Email This Post

Discuss this article

James B. Eavers March 5, 2010

Even after the recent tax increase on businesses, our rates are still very low. And we don’t hamstring our businesses with the number of regulations that NY, IL or CA do. So it is not that the state is “unfriendly to business”.

1 We spend little on education. Not only does that mean we don’t generate great employees for corporations, we also don’t have the cushion of a huge number of traditionally recession resistant jobs at universities.

2. We have no large military bases to cushion the economy

3. We are very resource dependent, and none of our resources are energy related.

4. We don’t have a huge port like Seattle, Oakland or LA. We get less exposure on the world stage.

5. Oregonians don’t welcome outsiders coming here. That’s different than the state being “unfriendly” due to supposedly high taxes. It’s just an attitude–if you are from the outside, you’re suspect.

6. The rich get richer: tech leaders like to be near other tech leaders. They like to be close to the action. They share information and ideas which generates more economic activity. We’re a backwater.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top Business News

 

Top Women's News

 

Top Natural Resource News

 

Top Faith News

 

Copyright © 2016, OregonReport. All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Use - Copyright - Legal Policy | Contact Oregon Report

Stay Tuned...

Stay up to date with the latest political news and commentary from Oregon Business Report through daily email updates:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Prefer another subscription option? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, become a fan on Facebook, or follow us on Twitter.

RSS Twitter Facebook

No Thanks (close this box)